Scientific communication is returning to its roots
A compelling piece in the Economist argues that social media are returning news to the "more vibrant, freewheeling, and discursive ways of the preindustrial era" and that newspapers will prove to have been a historical aberration. The same, I think, will be true of scientific journals.
The first mass circulation newspaper, the Sun, appeared in New York in 1833. It cost one sixth of existing papers and soon sold 15
000 copies, three times as much as any other paper. Before that news travelled mainly by word of mouth in markets and taverns, although some writings spread rapidly rather as some emails and videos "go viral" these days. Luther's writings reached all parts of Germany in two weeks in 1518, and within six months of its publication in January 1776 Thomas Paine's pamphlet Common Sense had
reached 250 000 people, half the population of what was about to become the USA.
Scientific journals began in the 17th century with
the French Journal des Savants and the British Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society. Before that and even afterwards scientists went to meetings and presented their studies. The assembled scientists would then discuss and critique the studies. We can imagine the intensity, energy, and passion of those meetings. This was the original peer review: immediate and open.
The Sun was soon copied, and mass circulation newspapers "put control of the flow of information into the hands of a select few." This
remained the dominant model of disseminating views for 170 years, until the arrival of the internet. Radio and television followed the same model as the newspapers, the few sent messages to the many. The many could send letters to the newspapers, but this was essentially one way communication.
In the same way journals came to dominate scientific communication. The New England Journal of Medicine began in 1812, the Lancet in 1823, and the BMJ in 1840. Nature began in 1869 and Science in 1880.
But, the Economist says of newspapers, "the internet has disrupted this model and allowed the social aspect of media to reassert itselfblogs, Facebook, and Twitter may seem entirely new but they echo the way in which people used to collect, share, exchange information in the past." Newspapers are now dying, and the Economist predicts that the media landscape will look very different by 2020 with only a few media organisations surviving the transition.
Although the "mass media era now looks like a relatively brief and anomalous," it is seen as normal by those who have spent their careers in those organisations. Those stuck in the "old paradigm" have great difficulty imagining and accepting the "new paradigm."
Scientific journals are lagging behind newspapers, but they are surely on the same course. Many find unacceptable the domination of a few
journals and the huge profits made by some publishers from the scientific value produced by others, and the open access has begun for these and other reasons. Open access articles are increasing rapidly, and just in the past few years we have seen the appearance of many "megajournals" like PLoS One and BMJ Open, which are aiming to publish rapidly after light peer review that does not attempt the largely impossible job of "spotting winners" but leaves readers to decide. Scientific blogs are becoming more important, and molecular biologists have for some time been leading the way by sharing their results immediately with each other through the internet.
We are slowly, as I've written many times before, moving to postpublication peer review where the scientific community judges what mattersnot bewigged and gathered in one elegant room as in the 18th century but connected globally through the internet. It's back to our roots.
Richard Smith was the editor of the BMJ until 2004 and is director of the United Health Group chronic disease initiative. Competing interest: RS is on the board of the Public Library of Science but is not paid.
Superb piece many thanks. And I think the impacts go beyond medical journals to clinicians themselves, who have also enjoyed a monopoly of knowledge until recent times
As an interested lay person, I'm sometimes frustrated by the
inaccessibility / cost of access to clinical studies, articles (etc.). So I look forward to evergreater openness in science and medicine. Here, we report a cluster of cases associated with a single family and describe an opensource genomic analysis of an isolate from one member of the family. This analysis involved the use of rapid, benchtop DNA sequencing technology, opensource data release, and prompt crowdsourced analyses. In less than a week, these studies revealed that the outbreak strain belonged to an enteroaggregativeE. colilineage that had acquired genes for Shiga toxin 2 and for antibiotic resistance.
An Outline Of Louis cheap nike air max
travel bags standard of luxury, the aristocracy especially over a hundred and
fifty long, is now a leader of fashion in the transport sector. Where prior to
the launch of its new selection, when the foot forward into a exclusive fashion
collection shortly before his distributor.
Like most of us know, Sunset cheap nike free run 3 Boulevard is a famous
street in the western part of Los
Angeles County, California.
However, there is something you do not know. Louis Vuitton outlet
came with the prestigious house with a new bag manufacturer extinguishing
Boulevard. This name is the perfect bag for a special occasion. Polished golden
brass leather match gorgeous patent extent.
Like I said, this bag is the name of one of the
world's most famous streets, Sunset Boulevard. This road is an icon of
Hollywood celebrity and Sunset Boulevard is durable short sentence in
connection with Hollywood.
Known as Sunset Boulevard, Louis Vuitton bag could expect a measure of the bags
are known, probably the best in the fashion scene. So Fashionable Istas has
this bag you happy?
Louis Vuitton fast lane cheap nike free run 1 could be the classic,
which is great for both travel and in the city. It is a reinterpretation of the
Keep all travel bag. The rounded interior evokes exceptionally spacious. The
rapid sequence could serve as a reseller of Louis Vuitton assumed to be the
Louis Vuitton bag can quickly and go with
everything from jeans to cocktail dress. It is also ideal for travel and takes
all your valuables in the same time, we will be fashionable. If you cost
personal style Louis Vuitton shop, do not want more than Speedy bag.
The purchase of a bag LV Monogram Vernis is an
investment in your future in fashion. LV Monogram flower and four said that
they are well known throughout the world. In fact, Louis Vuitton model
identification of the most expensive names in the world, in spite of the
products. But just like wearing a bag Vuitton Monogram brown and beige Louis
can be a confirmation of the trend of excellence, you are not carrying a bag
dark brown and beige. Do not go with the little black dress is so well
supported clubs. Fortunately, the LV Monogram Vernis actions that gap is
This collection of handbags and purses combined
iconic Louis Vuitton Monogram nike air max Vernis gloss paint, which was popular in France
during the reign of Louis XV. Originally, it was absolutely a copy with China,
that the paint all the changes became effective with the rich and the mainland.
Today Lv created this style of its staff. Handbags
wholesale light varnish. Not only a more brilliant shine of the paint, yet
allows the unique wealth shine through with the leather. The leather is not up
to standard-based brown, though. Available colors have red, orange, blue,
green, pink and black. Vernis bags are one color, any combination of jewel
tones would be the overwhelming shadow. The monogram is engraved on the skin
and shiny surface allows you to leave as soon as the light hits it right. This
way you can the true owner of Louis Vuitton bring change without having a kind
If the designer bags like Louis Vuitton Monogram
Canvas Batignolles Horizontal handbag is concerned, it is necessary to say that
we should take from exactly the same, cheap nike air max 90 although they can nike free run top-quality portfolio
of high-speed. The effects can not be that something would come up or maybe
open a button or zipper in this poor region cheap nike air max 1 to care. However, the investment in
the measures necessary to ensure that expensive really well in shape and
appearance to, it is as new as the day was absolutely bought. Frankly, ladies
should take care of your LV
bags, even when it comes to designer bags or not the Louis Vuitton Cup will
come in two cheap nike free run 2 copies in this respect.
Do you interest
in Louis Vuitton? Pay attention to lvlouisvuittonoutlet.
There are many Louis Vuitton
storm stirred up by Bill Fujimoto's recent resignation as manager of Monterey Market in Berkeley might seem surprising to some. But in Berkeley, perhaps more than anywhere else in the United States, passions run high over produce, and under Fujimoto's direction, Monterey Market became iconic for its support for smallscale local, and sustainable farming, cheap nike air max 1
its reputation parallel to that of the nearby Chez Panisse.
Fujimoto's knowledge cheap nike air max 90
of produce varieties, seasons and growing areas, his contacts with farmers and his encouragement of them to plant neglected or little known specialty items, such as Sierra Beauty apples and Pixie tangerines, have amplified his influence far beyond the San Francisco Bay Area. And more than his expertise, his humility and integrity have inspired intense loyalty in the market's suppliers, customers and employees.
"Bill Fujimoto is the only one of his kind in the United States," said John Kirkpatrick, a citrus farmer in Lindcove, Calif. "I'm looking for other markets to sell to."
But now, Fujimoto is out after a dispute among family members.
Less than five months after its splashy grand opening, spacious Korean supermarket Doremi and its adjacent noodle shop Doremi Udon (located on Olympic Boulevard near Hoover) have shut their doors. There are plenty of other Korean markets big and small in Koreatown including Market World half a mile west at Olympic and Berendo but it's always sad to see one bite the dust. You'll just have to go elsewhere for your gallon jugs of kimchi and assortment of Korean fruits, vegetables, juices, seasonings, seafood, candy and noodles.
The parking lot is locked, the shelves have been stripped and calls to the market, cheap nike air max
the noodle shop and Sunny Hill Group Inc. have gone cheap nike free run
unanswered or unreturned.
The Santa Barbara Independent reports that the venerable Wine Cask has closed. Calls to the restaurant and wine store Thursday and today were unanswered. Here's what the Independent says:
One of Santa Barbara wine country's most historic and influential businesses closed its downtown doors for good, as the owners of the Wine Cask restaurant and wine store as well as the Intermezzo wine bar told their employees that there'd no longer be jobs for them. The surprise shutdown comes less than two years after longtime owner Doug Margerum sold the business to senior care mogul and Los Angeles area restaurateur Bernard Rosenson. According to the landlord, SIMA Property Management, the closure resulted from an eviction.
According to the Santa Barbara Independent, Rosenson was unavailable for comment. Times restaurant critic S. Irene Virbila reviewed the Wine Cask's restaurant last year after Rosenson "spruced up the place a bit" nike air max
and installed John Pettitt, former chef de cuisine at Melisse, as the new chef. Among the changes noted:
Shortly after his purchase, Rosenson cut down the shaggy eucalyptus tree that had anchored the Wine Cask's courtyard patio for decades a move that hasn't endeared him to locals. For the new owner, the tree had a certain nuisance factor, shedding leaves and droppings on the patio, so off it went to that log pile in the sky.
Maybe that tree had been good luck.
Owner David Myers (whose empire of restaurants Sona, Comme a and, most recently, Pizzeria Ortica in Orange County continues to expand) and baker Hidefumi Kubota told the Daily Dish that they would be putting their energies into a new Comme a Bakery instead.
Fans of the shop's macarons, chocolate sables and sea salt caramels might ask, why close Boule? "It's nike free run
pretty simple," Myers says. "We've had incredible demand for our breads. I'm so passionate about what Hide's doing and he's so talented when it comes to baking bread. Unfortunately, our location [at Boule] doesn't give us the right space to delve deeply into bread."
Comme a Bakery's retail shop will be down the street from the current Boule location on La Cienega, and is set to open this summer, next to the space planned for Myers' forthcoming second outpost of Ortica. Myers is moving the bread baking operation into a 10,000squarefoot facility in Culver City. (Comme a Bakery also will be offering the bread wholesale.)
More bad news from the front lines of the recession. Beloved San Francisco chocolate maker Scharffen Berger will shut down its two Bay Area facilities, current owner Hershey Co. announced Tuesday. The San nike air max 90
Francisco Chronicle reported yesterday that Scharffen Berger's selection of sweets "will no longer be locally made" and that "Hershey already makes the majority of its Scharffen Berger products at its newly upgraded plant in Robinson, Ill." Still, 150 people up north will be affected by the dual plant closings.
And while most tourists buying lastminute gifts from SFO International Airport (one of the many places bittersweet Scharffen Berger products were available in the greater San Francisco area) for friends certainly won't know the difference now that the chocolate will now be made in Illinois, Bay Area fans of Scharffen Berger have a right to lament the loss of what was becoming a cherished San Francisco brand to rival the Ghirardelli Chocolate Co.
Scharffen Berger was founded in 1996 by Robert Steinberg, a familypractice physician in San Francisco and Ukiah, along with a former patient, winemaker John Scharffenberger.
The pair experimented in Steinberg's kitchen, using everything from a mortar and pestle to a hair dryer to create their chocolate. Production started in nike air max 1
a South San Francisco plant but was moved to the larger, 27,000squarefoot Berkeley factory in 2001.
"It was home grown. They really changed the way people regarded chocolate in this country," said Deborah Kwan, a public relations consultant for the company from the time it opened until 2003.